SM Architects, PLLC v. AMX Veteran Specialty Servs., LLC, 2018 Tex. App. LEXIS 9203 (November 8, 2018)
AMX Veteran Specialty Services, LLC (“AMX”) filed a demand for arbitration alleging professional negligence against SM Architects, PLLC (“SMA”). A Texas statute requires a plaintiff in an action or arbitration involving architectural services to file a certificate of merit affidavit by a third-party licensed architect in support of its claims. AMX attempted to meet this requirement by attaching an unsigned letter by an architect to its demand.
AMX twice amended its demand. It attached to its second amended demand a signed certificate of merit affidavit by the same architect. The affidavit was substantially similar to the original unsigned letter, but with added information regarding SMA’s alleged negligence.
SMA moved to dismiss AMX’s claims for failure to comply with the certificate of merit requirement. SMA argued that the unsigned letter submitted with AMX’s first demand for arbitration was not an affidavit, and that the affidavit filed with its second amended demand was ineffective because its failure to file an affidavit contemporaneously with the first-filed complaint could not be cured by amendment. The arbitration panel denied SMA’s motion. Continue reading “Although Texas Statute Expressly Allows an Immediate Interlocutory Appeal of Any Decision Granting or Denying a Motion to Dismiss Based Upon the Certificate of Merit Requirement, There Is No Jurisdiction for an Interlocutory Appeal of an Arbitrator’s Decision on That Issue”